Home » Have you adequately documented GST in your commercial property sale contract?
Written by: Ya Zhang

How does GST work?

In a sale of commercial property, the GST liability for a taxable supply could be substantial due to the high value of the commercial property. Where GST is payable for a sale of commercial property, many vendors believe that they always have the right to claim the GST amount from the purchasers.  Unfortunately, it is not the case.

 

Under the A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (the “GST Act”), a supplier is liable to pay GST on its taxable supplies. However, the GST Act does not grant the supplier a statutory right to charge an additional amount on account of GST to the recipient of its taxable supply. Instead, the GST Act leaves the supplier to recover such GST amounts from recipients under the contractual arrangements between them. For this reason, if the terms of the commercial property sale contract are silent or ambiguous on the GST arrangement, the vendor may not be able to charge the GST amount from the purchaser.

 

Where do disputes arise?

There have been many cases involving disputes between parties to commercial property transactions since the enactment of the GST Act. Some of the common contractual disputes between parties include, for example:

  • whether amounts stated in the contracts are inclusive or exclusive of GST;
  • whether the vendor is contractually entitled to recover an additional amount for GST from the purchaser;
  • whether there is an enforceable obligation on the vendor to refund a GST component to the purchaser where the supply is not taxable;
  • whether the GST clause is void because of uncertainty and therefore needs to be severed from the contract.

 

How do I avoid a dispute over GST?

The above disputes can be largely avoided if you have included a well drafted GST clause in your contract. The most basic operation of a GST clause is to enable the supplier of a taxable supply to recover an additional amount from the recipient to cover the supplier’s GST liability on the taxable supply. One of the most common areas of dispute has been whether the consideration stated in the contract is:

  • GST-inclusive; or
  • GST-exclusive and subject to a GST gross-up.

 

Merely stating amounts are “GST-exclusive” does not necessarily give rise to a right to gross-up. Parties to contracts should remember that the expression “exclusive of GST” does not create an implied obligation on the purchaser to pay the GST. Similarly, merely stating amounts are “GST-inclusive” does not create an implied obligation on the vendor to refund a GST component to the purchaser where the supply is not taxable. Therefore, if agreed by the parties, vendor’s right to gross-up and obligation to refund should be expressly stated in the GST clause to avoid potential disputes.

 

Sometimes, the vendor and the purchase may agree to apply certain GST treatments to a supply (e.g. supply of a going concern, which means the transaction is GST-free). However, if such agreed treatment is later determined by the ATO to be incorrect, it raises the question on which party is responsible for the penalties or interest imposed by the ATO. This is another question that should be negotiated and agreed by the parties in the GST clause, especially where the parties’ agreed treatment involves a high level of uncertainty.

Contact Us

Given the complexity of GST treatments in commercial property transactions and the associated risks to relevant parties, it is crucial to seek legal and tax advice before signing a contract. A good GST clause will ensure that your GST position is adequately documented and protected.

 

Martin Mitchell
2023-12-23
Greenhalgh Pickard is a tightly woven network of highly professional solicitors and staff professionals who walked me through a difficult legal process, coaching and reassuring me every step of the way. Rob Hollis was the right solicitor for me the moment I met him, and I appreciated him keeping me in the loop about filed papers and every little step that needed to be handled to move the case forward to a successful and speedy conclusion. Rob and the legal teams in Greenhalgh Pickard did a great job for me with property settlement and my divorce , updated Will and EPA. From the initial consultation on they really set the firm apart from others , the time they take to simplify and explain strategy with the elements of case law to the uninitiated. I was also very satisfied with Shania’s latest guidance and advice on Wills/EPA update. There is no shortage of divorce solicitors but finding the best fit for your particular situation is a challenge. Rob and their work set themselves apart to your advantage and peace of mind.
Lana Chapman
2023-12-20
Tori and John are exceptional solicitors! They helped us mitigate our legal situation with precision and expertise. They provided great legal counsel and were proactive communicators. They collaborated with our accountant (Jason- also highly recommend in their business) to ensure we were able to navigate complexities and we were provided top-notch service. Trustworthy, responsive, and results-driven. Highly recommend.
Amy McCarthy
2023-11-30
Very happy with the service from Jessica and the team at Greenhalgh Pickard. This was my first time purchasing a home so I didn’t quite know what to expect - Jessica gave great advice and the process was executed flawlessly. Highly recommend.
Gabrielle Worrall
2023-11-28
The legal and accounting teams have been great to deal with and very professional, definitely reccommend!
Mark Edwards
2023-11-28
We used Greenhalgh Pickard Solicitors for the purchase of our property. Professional, efficient, and approachable. Thanks so much to Ella and the team. We will be sure to use them again.
John Ryan
2023-11-24
Very happy with every part of our dealings with Greenhalgh Pickard Solicitors. Everyone involved made us very comfortable and were very helpful and clear with any questions we had. Would highly recommend.
Greg Andrew
2023-11-23
Highly recommend the team at Greenhalgh Pickard after our experience with them. Highly professional, friendly and excellent communication at all times! Very grateful for their prompt service.
Brendon Bolt
2023-11-21
Eloise was very helpful in assisting on some business matters. Her and her team were very professional and knowledgeable and provided assistance in a timely manner.
Haileigh Stokes
2023-11-16
I highly recommend Tori and the team. Tori has been an incredible help with my recent commercial property lease. Tori took the time to explain everything and was always easy to contact via phone or email.
Troy Hartup
2023-11-06
This is the second time I have engaged the team at Greenhalgh Pickard and I cannot recommend them highly enough. Jessica went above and beyond to help me secure a block of land interstate and I can not fault her level of expertise, professionalism or friendliness. I was always kept informed and any questions I had were answered swiftly. Jessica made this process seem simple from start to finish and I am very happy. Thank you Jessica.